Female Heroes in Literature

Front Cover ONLY-web-smaller (1)For my birthday last year, I went to the cinema to watch the popular—and somewhat controversial—Hunger Games. Well, controversial among some critics and followers of critics, anyway. I came across a particularly juicy tidbit by critic Jeffrey Wells on Hollywood Elsewhere, in which he attributed the movie’s success to “reviews by certain female critics” who are “susceptible to the lore of this young-female-adult-propelled franchise.”  Whether this was true or not—and I highly doubt this— it brings up another stirring question: that of gender-bias. Is it truly still hard for a man like Wells to accept and enjoy a story which feature’s a female heroine?  Is it so hard to see a woman as a person first: championing a cause, delivering a world from evil and injustice, overcoming a great obstacle to become enlightened? I think of my favorite stories in literature, peopled by men and women; all heroes: Tess of the d’Urbervilles, Fahrenheit 451, King Lear, Solaris, The Grapes of Wrath, 1984, Doctor Zhivago, Brave New World, and To Kill a Mockingbird — to name a few. The gender of the hero I empathized with was irrelevant. What remained important was their sensibilities and their actions.

It got me thinking … What does it take to be a hero—a female hero— particularly? And does there need to be a difference? The tweets and FB talk and internet buzz out there imply that male heroes differ from female heroes; they embrace differing quests and archetypal roles and reflect different qualities. For instance, the male hero stereotype in literature and films of western culture is often characterized by strength, courage, integrity & honor, intelligence, assertiveness, single-mindedness, faith in his quest, and boundless determination: he is the altruist warrior, often acting alone against an unfair society through his conscience. All traits honored, respected and esteemed in men. In a woman, these Boadicean qualities often qualify her as “a bitch” or “a guy in drag”. She may be considered unwomanly, unlady-like, intimidating and perhaps even a “tomboy” with lesbian tendencies. Not the sort of girl you would take home to mummy. The exciting Becky Sharp to the prosaic but sweet Amelia. And God forbid that she be more intelligent than her male counterpart!

For a woman to qualify as “hero” then, must she shed her feminine qualities of compassion, kindness, tenderness, and nurturing, to express those hero-defining qualities that are typically considered “male”? Are they so diametrically opposed? I think not. I know not. Truly three dimensional woman deserve better than that in literature and other story media.  I have seen too many 2-dimensional female characters limited by their own stereotype; limited to a 2-dimensional role of enabling the “real hero” on his journey through their belief in him: as Trinity enables Neo; Hermione enables Harry; Mary Jane enables Spiderman; Lois enables Superman; etc. etc. etc.

In an opinion piece in the Detroit News, Tom Long tells us that the women in top hero-style movies have usually been and still are portrayed in “romantic, sidekick or comedic roles. Often they’re waiting to be rescued (think Princess Leia). And some of them are part of action ensembles [think X-men].” Token figures to provide added “spice”, edge and diversity. This is, according to Gitesh Pandya, editor of a box office analyst site, because female-driven action movies have a hard time selling. “Most of the action films that have become huge hits are either male-driven or ensemble.” Pandya goes on to suggest that this is because more tickets are purchased by men than by women. “The film industry has been male-dominated for so long, the people who are creating and financing these films typically put men in there as heroes.” And yet women read far more fiction than men (by a 4:1 ratio according to some sources). We are in dire need of balance and we hunger for a female hero.

“What does it mean for our nation or our world if we treat [women] by a different script? What are we clinging to when we cling to that script that women need men’s protection?” said Ann Folino White, assistant professor at Michigan State University. She does well to call it a script when the storytellers of a culture define our humanity: who and what we are, our values and what we strive to be. Storytellers are the shamans of our culture and our time. We are the visionaries of our future.

I’ve included a list of my recommended books with female heroes. You’ll note that I’ve included some of mine; I do this not out of hubris but because I make a point of writing the kind of stories with strong female heroes that I like to read. There are many more out there. Please add yours.

The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins (Scholastic Press). 2008. A series of books about teens forced to fight to the death on television.

The Steel Seraglio by Mike Carey, Linda Carey, Louise Carey and Nimit Malavia (Chizine Publications). 2012. A novel about the women of a harem in an ancient Middle Eastern kingdom, who forge themselves into an army after they’re exiled from the city of their birth — and then return to claim the city for themselves.

The Splintered Universe Trilogy by Nina Munteanu (Starfire World Syndicate). 2011/2012/2013. This trilogy, starting with Outer Diverse, follows the quest of anti-social Galactic Guardian Rhea Hawke who must solve the massacre of a spiritual sect that takes her on her own metaphoric journey of self-discovery to embrace the world.

Darwin’s Paradox duology by Nina Munteanu (Dragon Moon Press). 2007/2010. An eco-thriller about a woman unjustly exiled for murder and her quest for justice in a world ruled by technology and scientists.

The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank. 1942. A powerful reminder of the horrors of war and an eloquent testament to the human spirit.

His Dark Materials Trilogy by Philip Pullman (Laurel Leaf). 2003. A fantasy alternate world adventure about a young girl who discovers that the fate of the universe lies in her hands.

A Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood (Anchor). 1998. A chilling fable of the near future, about a monotheocratic government where women are strictly controlled and assigned roles.

Related Posts

Mocking Jay Trailer Suggests Film May Be Better Than the Book

Mocking Jay Trailer Suggests Film May Be Better Than the Book

An Interview with K. D. Emerson

Steve Fahnestalk’s VCON 39 Report. NOT R. Graeme Cameron’s VCON 39 Report!

Steve Fahnestalk’s VCON 39 Report. NOT R. Graeme Cameron’s VCON 39 Report!

2 thoughts on "Female Heroes in Literature"

  1. Thanks for sharing, Marilynn. Great choices!
    Best,
    Nina

  2. Profile photo of Marilynn Byerly says:

    My brother-in-law, my nephew who is in his mid-twenties, and I (female) were discussing movies, and I was the only one who won’t watch an occasional chick-flick.

    I prefer explosions and strong women over an emotionally clueless women with shoe fetishes going after men as emotionally clueless.

    I also don’t like women who are men with breasts as action heroes.

    Book series I would recommend are

    Mercedes Lackey’s fairy tale series and her Elemental Masters. Both historical fantasies. They are suitable for adults and young adults, and the heroines are more likely to be bookworms or scholars than mistresses of mayhem. The men also don’t follow the standard macho patterns.

    Jim Butcher’s “Dresden Files” for the secondary character Karrin Murphy, a tiny woman of great courage and integrity who can hold her own against monsters and mobsters. They are suitable for adults and older teens. Urban fantasy.

    Marjorie M. Liu’s Maximer Kiss series with a middle-aged heroine who kicks demon butt and has a mature relationship with a her lover. Urban fantasy.

    Patricia Brigg’s traditional fantasies as well as her Mercy Thompson series which are urban fantasy. The traditional fantasies are more youth friendly.

    Andre Norton’s “Witchworld” traditional fantasy novels. Suitable for teens and adults.

    Ilona Andrews’ Kate Daniels urban fantasy series. Adults.

    Shawn Thomas Odyssey’s Oona Crate fantasies written for ‘tweens. The heroine prefers logic and deduction over using magic to solve crimes.

Leave a Reply