Dear Amazing Stories Readers: We've been bringing you daily content since 2012 as well as having published online three issues of Amazing Stories. Now we're asking for your help to bring back the print edition of the Amazing Stories magazine. Please visit our Kickstarter page and make your donation to restart the world's original Science Fiction magazine. Consider this, if just half of our 41,000+ members gave $10 to get the digital subscription we would be fully funded for nearly two years!

Click and Contribute at Kickstarter

Amazing Stories

The Greatest Science Fiction Novels of All Time Part 4

scientifiction_feature1Welcome to the ever-growing list of the greatest science fiction novels of all time.

This week we are venturing back in time before many of the modern awards were conceived–a time when novels were still finding their way onto shelves. Science fiction at its core began with the short fiction found in pulp magazines. Later, longer stories began to appear as serializations in the magazines.

Still later, it was discovered that readers did enjoy science fiction novels. The 1950s and 1960s represented a transition period for science fiction. Many of the greatest science fiction novels of all time started out serialized in magazines.

We have been compiling a list of the greatest science fiction novels of all time here in the electronic pages of Amazing Stories Magazine. We have been trying to judge each book objectively by focusing on the number of awards and nominations bestowed upon each tale.

The first three parts of our exploration selected novels published in the 1970s. This week we will venture a bit further back in time. We will target a novel that was written when fewer awards existed. It was written when many science fiction authors still relied on magazines as their first launching point for a new novel.

Before we get on with this week’s entry, let’s look back at our list so far.

The Greatest Science Fiction Novels of All Time

  • Rendezvous on Rama by Arthur C. Clarke (Best Novel Awards: Hugo 1974, Nebula 1973, Locus 1974, Campbell 1974,  British Science Fiction Association 1973, Jupiter 1974, Seiun 1980)
  • Gateway by Frederik Pohl (Best Novel Awards:  Hugo 1978, Nebula 1977, Locus 1978, Campbell 1978)
  • The Dispossessed by Ursula K. Le Guin (Best Novel Awards: Hugo 1975, Nebula 1975, Locus 1975, Jupiter 1975; Nominations: Campbell 1975)

Dune by Frank HerbertDune by Frank Herbert

Title: Dune

Author: Frank Herbert

First Year Published: 1965


  • Nebula Award for Best Novel 1966
  • Hugo Award for Best Novel 1966



  • Hugo Award for Best Novel 1964 (Dune World see below)


If you are a science fiction fan and have never heard of Dune, then consider this an early birthday gift. Go out and pick up a copy and add it to your reading list.

Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) Grand Master Frank Herbert originally wrote the novel as two shorter novels that were serialized in the pages of the magazine Analog Science Fact & Fiction. Herbert had grown a deeper understanding and appreciation for sand dunes through a research trip to the Oregon Dunes–that’s right the Oregon Dunes. Yes, that Oregon.

Dune World by Frank HerbertHis research inspired him to begin work on two shorter novels he called Dune World and The Prophet of Dune. Dune World earned a Hugo for Best Novel nomination in 1964, meaning parts of Dune were nominated for two different Hugos for Best Novel.

After the two were wisely serialized in Analog, Frank pulled them together and began editing and combining them into what would become his masterpiece. He would later go on to write five sequels to the novel, but some would say that none of the sequels ever reached the same level of excellence as the original.

Since his passing, the novel has continued to gain sequels and prequels with the aid of his son Brian Herbert and author Kevin J. Anderson.

The original Dune is said to be the bestselling science fiction novel of all time. Estimates put the number of copies sold somewhere in the neighborhood of 10-12 million.

Hollywood has fallen in love with the book. The rights were originally acquired in 1971, but the proposed 14-hour film never made it beyond preproduction. After a decade of lingering in back rooms, the rights changed hands and finally made it to the big screen.

(L to R:) David Lynch and Frank Herbert

David Lynch and Frank Herbert

Filmmaker Dino De Laurentiis  turned to David Lynch to write and direct the film, choosing Lynch’s script over one written by Frank Herbert himself. The film was nominated for an Oscar, three Saturn Awards, and the Hugo for Best Dramatic Presentation. It managed to win one Saturn Award for Best Costumes. The award was presented by the Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA.

In 2000, Dune was again adapted by Hollywood, this time for the small screen, appearing as a miniseries on the Sci-Fi Channel. The series remains one of the highest rated showings on the cable channel. It received nominations for the Saturn Award, Primetime Emmy, ASC Award, C.A.S. Award, Golden Reel Award, and the Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation. The Dune miniseries won two Primetime Emmy Awards and a Golden Reel Award.

In 2008, Paramount Pictures planned another run at a big screen release. With escalating production costs, the studio executives were looking for a script they could hold under $175 million. Unfortunately they were unable to wrestle the script into a workable adaptation, so the project was abandoned. We can only hope that someone will eventually solve the riddle of Dune and bring a modern adaptation to the big screen (or perhaps an HBO series).

Besides Dune’s success in Hollywood, it has also managed to find its way into numerous computer, board, role-playing, and card games. The world Frank Herbert created six decades ago has a depth that lends itself to infinite possibilities.

Kwisatz Haderach

Kwisatz Haderach

The novel itself paints the story of humanity’s far future–a future where great houses plot and scheme their way to power, and religious sects manipulate bloodlines to spawn the ultimate human, the Kwisatz Haderach.

The planet Dune is at the center of the struggle for control of the known universe. The desert planet is the lone source for the spice mélange. The spice is used for travelling great distances in space and for unlocking higher thinking in the human mind. Mélange and the struggle for its control reminds some of the struggle for oil in the Middle East of modern day Earth.

Frank Herbert delivers amazing action, eye-opening insight, and a wonderfully twisted plot. The complex world he created includes a detailed government, religion, and ecology. The depth of his characters are on par with the greatest novels written in any genre. Dune offers something for every science fiction fan to savor.

Frank Herbert’s Dune is one of the greatest science fiction novels of all time.

2 thoughts on "The Greatest Science Fiction Novels of All Time Part 4"

  1. I love the David Lynch film version even though it leaves a great deal unsaid. You would have thought that Dune would be perfect for a Game of Thrones type continuing series on HBO or a similar channel. As you say, it has the same complex world view, warring families, and enough complexity and richness to last over several seasons. Perhaps it’s just a question of getting hold of the rights.

  2. L Balsam says:

    The book was great and memorable.

    The theatrical stank.

    The SyFy series was wonderful.

Leave a Reply